Superstar Weekly

Authenticity has long been considered the cornerstone of influencer marketing because it builds trust, engagement and loyalty between influencers and their audiences, which is crucial for effective endorsements. 

However, in a time where anyone, including AI, can rise to influencer status, does authenticity still hold its value? Or have we entered an era where the number of followers matters more than authenticity?

Sprout Social’s 2024 Influencer Marketing Report offers a mixed view. While nearly half of all consumers (49%) make purchases influenced by influencers daily, weekly, or monthly, and trust in influencers is rising, the preferences across generations show a significant divide. Only 35% of Gen Z value authenticity most, compared to 47% who prioritize follower counts.

This trend extends to Millennials and Gen Z, who often rank an influencer’s reputation and metrics, such as posting frequency and follower count (58% and 42%, respectively), above personal values and authenticity (32% and 21%).

So, what does this mean for brands? Is authenticity still king? Should brands use AI influencers?

There’s no denying the allure of AI influencers. They offer brands the potential for scalability, targeted messaging, and data-driven content optimization. AI influencers could significantly reduce marketing expenses. They can also operate round-the-clock, engaging with audiences and driving sales even during off-peak hours. Moreover, Advanced AI can enable virtual influencers to customize their interactions based on viewer comments and preferences. The possibilities seem endless.

But is this a recipe for success or a path towards sterile, inauthentic influencer marketing campaigns that ultimately fizzle out? 

The key lies in the core of what defines a successful creator—their ability to forge emotional connections and build trust, which is rooted in authenticity. People are drawn to influencers who are genuine and transparent with their intentions. When influencers genuinely appreciate a product, their endorsements feel sincere, enhancing the credibility and effectiveness of their recommendations.

While AI can generate flawless content, it lacks the lived experiences and raw vulnerability that resonate with human audiences. We yearn for voices that echo our struggles, celebrate our triumphs, and speak truths from the heart —elements that AI cannot replicate despite its complexities.

The initial allure of AI-generated content’s polished perfection might captivate. Still, its flawlessness often comes across as cold, soulless, and inauthentic. It’s the imperfections—the unscripted moments of joy and despair—that reveal the true story and spur people to action.

And, as synthetic content becomes more prevalent, trust built on authentic engagement will only become more critical.

Ultimately, AI will not alter our fundamental human needs for connection, imperfection, originality, trust, and self-expression. These are the cornerstones of authenticity, and it is upon this foundation that influencer marketing will continue to thrive in an AI-infused future.

Free Creator Economy Resource List

Looking for the latest news and insights on the creator economy? We’ve curated a selection of top industry resources—all continuously updated—to help marketers stay informed and navigate the creator economy more effectively. Check it out here 👇

Industry spotlight

YouTube’s reused content policy and its legal implications

YouTube Creator Liaison Rene Ritchie recently sat down with Thomas Kim, Director of Product Management—Creator Monetization at YouTube, to discuss the platform’s reused content policy and its implications. Read more here

After years of caution, pharma advertisers are embracing influencer marketing

Brand advertisers in the health and pharma sector are among the highest spenders on media agency books. Historically, they’ve avoided influencer marketing, but now they’re channelling more of their media budgets into the creator economy. Read more here

Instagram updates feed algorithm to prioritize original and emerging creators

After weeks of telling creators to “stop crying” about their reach and follower counts, Instagram has announced a significant algorithm update designed to help ensure original content posters get more traction, as opposed to those who repost their work, while also giving smaller accounts more opportunity. Read more here

Starpower

Nikon unveils partnership program taping 9 trailblazing creators to redefine visual storytelling

Imaging and optics company Nikon Inc. is launching its “Nikon Creators Official Partners” program. This initiative connects Nikon with nine emerging visual artists reshaping creative disciplines such as photography and videography. Read more here

MrBeast ditches talent management firm Night Media

Jimmy Donaldson, better known as MrBeast, is allegedly parting ways with talent management company Night Media to increase personal control over his multi-million dollar media empire. Read more here

Issa Rae’s new management company connects brands with diverse creators, with big brands already on board

Issa Rae’s new company, Ensemble, aims to connect creators and brands for deeper relationships beyond the typical influencer-sponsor partnership. The company has already assembled a network of 50 creators, including Drew Afualo, Leo González, and Mark Phillips, and is collaborating with brands like Pepsi, Chili’s, and Popeyes. Read more here

Sara Tendulkar, daughter of legendary cricketer Sachin Tendulkar, just scored a huge beauty deal with a big Korean brand

Korean beauty brand Laneige has named social media influencer Sara Tendulkar its new Brand Ambassador in India. The partnership aims to connect the brand with a broader, younger audience. Read more here

Interesting-reads

Jolie shower heads are all over social media—and that’s by design [Link]

Does Generative AI content have a place in social media? [Link]

Bracing for post-TikTok social: 20 industry voices discuss creators’ and users’ next destinations [Link]

The Death of the Follower - The Next Era of Content Creation [Link]

How this 23-year-old entrepreneur built a multi-million dollar influencer agency while battling cancer as a teen [Link]

Join the conversation

Visit our Creator Marketing Community on LinkedIn to connect with leading creator marketing experts worldwide. Share your thoughts, gain valuable industry insights, and keep pace with the latest trends.