Is your influencer marketing stuck in Single-Touch mode?

The early days of Influencer marketing were all about celebrity endorsements and social media buzz. Brands used influencers to get noticed, hoping for a sprinkle of brand magic to boost visibility and generate initial engagement.

But things have changed.

Today's brands are now placing a premium on ROI and de-emphasizing vanity metrics like likes and shares. Instead, they are prioritizing conversion metrics that have a direct impact on revenue. Decision-makers are now demanding more precise and detailed metrics that can clearly demonstrate how influencers influence the customer journey and drive sales.

However, this shift has presented a significant challenge for influencer marketing teams that continue to depend on single-touch attribution models. These models, while easy to implement, offer a limited view, hindering their ability to accurately measure ROI and optimize campaigns.

The Limitations of Single-Touch Attribution Models

Single-touch attribution models fail to capture the full spectrum of interactions contributing to a customer’s decision to purchase, thereby misrepresenting the effectiveness of various touchpoints. As a result, key influencer activities that generate initial interest and nurture leads are undervalued or ignored, leading to an incomplete and distorted view of their true impact on conversions.

First-Touch Attribution (First Click)

This model assigns 100% of the conversion credit to the customer’s first interaction with your brand. This can overemphasize the importance of initial touchpoints while ignoring subsequent engagements that may be crucial in driving conversions.

Example: A customer sees an Instagram story from Influencer A (Sarah) and clicks through to the brand’s website but doesn’t purchase. Later, they see a post from Influencer B (David) and decide to buy. First-touch attribution gives Sarah all the credit, even though David’s post was pivotal in closing the sale.

Last-Touch Attribution (Last Click)

This model assigns 100% of the credit to the final touchpoint a customer interacts with before converting, undervaluing the role of earlier engagements that helped build awareness and interest.

Example: A customer first engages with a post from Influencer A (Sarah) but doesn’t buy immediately. They later see a post from Influencer B (David) and make a purchase. Last-touch attribution credits David with the entire conversion, overlooking Sarah’s role in initiating the customer journey.

These models fail to capture the full spectrum of interactions contributing to a customer’s decision to purchase, thereby misrepresenting the effectiveness of various touchpoints. As a result, key influencer activities that generate initial interest and nurture leads are undervalued or ignored, leading to an incomplete and distorted view of their true impact on conversions.

This inaccurate attribution not only skews performance metrics but also complicates the justification of marketing expenditures to stakeholders, making it difficult to secure future budgets. Influencer marketing teams struggle to optimize their strategies effectively without comprehensively understanding how each touchpoint contributes to sales and revenue growth. This results in inefficient use of resources and missed opportunities to enhance campaign performance and overall ROI.

Enter Multi-Touch Attribution

Multi-touch attribution credits each marketing touchpoint that influences a customer’s conversion instead of just the first or last touchpoint. It involves analyzing a conversion event, such as a customer purchase, and evaluating each touchpoint’s role in that event. It tracks and analyses customer interactions across various channels and touchpoints. Data is collected using tools like tracking pixels, cookies, and unique URLs with UTM parameters to monitor engagements such as social media interactions, website visits, and email clicks.

Advanced algorithms then analyze this data to determine the relative importance of each touchpoint, distributing credit according to different models: linear attribution (equal credit to all touchpoints), time decay attribution (more credit to touchpoints closer to conversion), and position-based attribution (more credit to the first and last interactions).

Marketers can allocate their budgets more strategically by identifying which influencers and touchpoints are most effective at different stages of the customer journey. Multi-touch attribution highlights where marketing spending is yielding the highest returns and where it might be falling short. This insight allows for better investment decisions, ensuring funds are directed towards influencers who drive the most value.

Multi-touch is gaining traction and likely to become the future standard for influencer marketing metrics

Accurate attribution is crucial for measuring the effectiveness of influencer marketing efforts. It helps marketers understand which channels and strategies are driving conversions, allowing for more informed decision-making and better allocation of resources.

One of the main benefits of multi-touch attribution is its ability to provide visibility into the effectiveness of touchpoints throughout the customer journey. It highlights the interactions that lead to conversions and offers a comprehensive view of how different influencers contribute to the overall success of a campaign. This, in turn, helps boost ROI by identifying where spending is most and least effective.

Ultimately, as investment in influencer marketing continues to rise, stakeholder demand for budget justification will inevitably increase. This will require influencer marketing teams to demonstrate clear, data-driven evidence of their impact on sales and revenue growth.

By leveraging multi-touch attribution, teams can provide detailed insights into the performance of each touchpoint, ensuring that every dollar spent is accounted for and justified. This level of transparency and accountability will not only help secure future budgets but also drive continuous improvement in campaign strategies and outcomes.

Free Creator Economy Resource List

Looking for the latest news and insights on the creator economy? We’ve curated a selection of top industry resources — all continuously updated— to help marketers navigate the creator economy more effectively. We’ve just added a global marketing events calendar! Check it out here 👇

Industry insights

[REPORT] The power of creators in evoking emotion & why it matters

A new study exploring the emotional impact of creator content has revealed the profound influence that creators have on consumer actions including brand consideration, purchase intent, and recommendation. Read the full report here

DTC company Shapermint’s AI influencer engine highlights how marketers are actually using the tech

Discover how Shapermint, a direct-to-consumer fashion brand, is using generative AI to scale up its influencer program through an AI agent that creates scripts and storyboards for influencers’ TikTok and Instagram Reels. Read more here

Influencer marketing is booming in 2024 as brands are taking creators more seriously

Industry insiders, including influencer-marketing firms and other experts, share their thoughts on how creator marketing has fared this year compared to 2023. Read more here

Interesting reads

What might a world without TikTok really look like for brands? [LINK]

The hottest influencers you've never heard of: your employees [LINK]

TikTok Shop is huge for the beauty industry [LINK]

Why industry insiders, from influencers to marketers, are cautiously optimistic about AI-powered ads [LINK]

The catalysts: Estée Lauder is betting $500k on 2 creators from TikTok’s beauty community [LINK]

Join the conversation

Visit our Creator Marketing Community on LinkedIn to connect with leading creator marketing experts worldwide. Share your thoughts, gain valuable industry insights, and keep pace with the latest trends.